Sunday, May 28, 2006
A beautiful day in SF
To get down to the day. Got out of the house by 9 am and were in the city, with its tricky one-ways by around 9:45 am. Surprisingly, we seemed to be the first gang at the designated spot though others had arrived before us.
The first tour lasted from 10 am to 11:30 am and was about the Gold Rush in 1848-49. The Gold Rush, for all practical reasons, built San Francisco and gave it the personality it has today. A city of opportunities for the risk takers and opportunity seekers.
Dave was a pretty interesting speaker, though he had an intriguing habit of spacing out in the middle of his monologue. I guess I'd need to take pics of Dave from the AK man.
We walked around looking at some of the spots where commerce had set up, including the offices of the Pony Express, the first mint, the center of the city from whence it has sprung, etc.
I'd elaborate on individual components some other day (heck, maybe even tomorrow)
After we were let off at 11:30 it was a short walk to Chinatown and some decent dimsum place. It was more 'homely' and not quite as good as Ton King at Geary, where we ended up in the Spring break for a nice hearty, sumptuous dimsum lunch.
After lunch, we drove over to the City Hall to our second walking tour...the earthquake of 1906. This is the centennial year...so it is kinda special for the city. The lady was in a typical Victorian dress and a hand made bonnet. Walked around the City Hall and some of the streets and alleys in the vicinity. She showed us where the "ham and eggs" fire had begun and approached the area between Market st and Van Ness. Also went through the Public library to see some remarkable old photographs.
One of the highlights of the day was seeing this beautiful vintage car and one of the most expensive ones at that- a 1937 Rolls Royce Phantom III. The chauffeur told me it was the first '100 miles an hr' car. Ain't it a beauty?
Saturday, May 20, 2006
Rang De Basanti
Here is a disclaimer (especially for those who don't know me)- By nature I detest violent approaches to enforce my world view. I didn't really like the approach RDB youth had taken. I don't think killing someone is a solution to anything.
Now I can write further.
The "no excuses" speech in the end made me look at RDB differently. As I read about the reservation firefights I feel a silent rage churning inside me. A lot of factors fuel this rage:
1) Political aspirations and sheer greed of individuals like Arjun Singh can threaten to lay waste a large country like India. It is Macbethian characters like him that are the bane of Indian existence. How many dead bodies of hard-working, smart Indians will he tread over before he stops?
2) The apparent abdication by my ex-idol Manmohan Singh. I revered him for his intelligence and his actions. I was happy that an intellectual of his calibre had decided to get his hands dirty in Indian politics. But now as I see him refusing to acknowledge the anti-reservations protests I am left despondent. He has followed a policy of minimum resistance to his baiters and minimum visibility to those who seek his true views.
Did even Hamlet ever face Dr. Singh's dilemma?
3) The refusal of other parties to join in the anti-reservation debate...no one wants to sit on a gun powder keg, light up a match and see their political prospects blown sky high.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
ToI
Meanwhile, BJP leader Sushma Swaraj beat a hasty retreat from AIIMS after the students asked her to take a clear stand on the reservation issue. Once they realised that no response was coming, they started shouting slogans and forced her to leave the venue.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
4) The lack of willingness on the part of regular, working or studying joes to come out into the street and to join in protests against this shameless act on the part of the government. It mystifies me, infuriates me to wonder...do these guys have no sense of social obligation and an obligation to their future generations? Their refusal to participate may be representative of their declining faith in the system, their personal lack of belief in the strength of their voice and in general a "chalta hai" attitude. Until John Doe becomes a social activist, no good can accrue.
Yet there is hope, I heard engineers are joining in and a batch of accountants joined in the protests in Delhi.
But all this begs a few questions...
1) Why have only doctors been the active participants in this crusade? Aren't MBAs, engineers, accountants or other occupations going to be hit by this piece of legislation?
2) Moreover, on the longer time scale...medical residents, engineers don't have unlimited time being only social activists. Their primary duty is an onerous and time-consuming duty whereas people like Arjun Singh, in the twilight of their life and career, looking back on a life ill-spent, have ample time to claim their one last moment in the spotlight, damn the cost. How do we keep the movement going without compromising our work life?
This certainly isn't going to be a 10-day fest affair. This monster is going to have to be battled longer and stronger.
People like Arjun Singh can push their agenda forward in the firm knowledge of the pacifist nature of people like us...we don't set buses on fire or lynch a minister. He needs to see that we can't be taken for granted and that if he is back to his bull shit...we will raise our voice...loudly!
All it takes for Evil to succeed is for a few good men to do nothing.
Rang De Basanti!
Now I can write further.
The "no excuses" speech in the end made me look at RDB differently. As I read about the reservation firefights I feel a silent rage churning inside me. A lot of factors fuel this rage:
1) Political aspirations and sheer greed of individuals like Arjun Singh can threaten to lay waste a large country like India. It is Macbethian characters like him that are the bane of Indian existence. How many dead bodies of hard-working, smart Indians will he tread over before he stops?
2) The apparent abdication by my ex-idol Manmohan Singh. I revered him for his intelligence and his actions. I was happy that an intellectual of his calibre had decided to get his hands dirty in Indian politics. But now as I see him refusing to acknowledge the anti-reservations protests I am left despondent. He has followed a policy of minimum resistance to his baiters and minimum visibility to those who seek his true views.
Did even Hamlet ever face Dr. Singh's dilemma?
3) The refusal of other parties to join in the anti-reservation debate...no one wants to sit on a gun powder keg, light up a match and see their political prospects blown sky high.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
ToI
Meanwhile, BJP leader Sushma Swaraj beat a hasty retreat from AIIMS after the students asked her to take a clear stand on the reservation issue. Once they realised that no response was coming, they started shouting slogans and forced her to leave the venue.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
4) The lack of willingness on the part of regular, working or studying joes to come out into the street and to join in protests against this shameless act on the part of the government. It mystifies me, infuriates me to wonder...do these guys have no sense of social obligation and an obligation to their future generations? Their refusal to participate may be representative of their declining faith in the system, their personal lack of belief in the strength of their voice and in general a "chalta hai" attitude. Until John Doe becomes a social activist, no good can accrue.
Yet there is hope, I heard engineers are joining in and a batch of accountants joined in the protests in Delhi.
But all this begs a few questions...
1) Why have only doctors been the active participants in this crusade? Aren't MBAs, engineers, accountants or other occupations going to be hit by this piece of legislation?
2) Moreover, on the longer time scale...medical residents, engineers don't have unlimited time being only social activists. Their primary duty is an onerous and time-consuming duty whereas people like Arjun Singh, in the twilight of their life and career, looking back on a life ill-spent, have ample time to claim their one last moment in the spotlight, damn the cost. How do we keep the movement going without compromising our work life?
This certainly isn't going to be a 10-day fest affair. This monster is going to have to be battled longer and stronger.
People like Arjun Singh can push their agenda forward in the firm knowledge of the pacifist nature of people like us...we don't set buses on fire or lynch a minister. He needs to see that we can't be taken for granted and that if he is back to his bull shit...we will raise our voice...loudly!
All it takes for Evil to succeed is for a few good men to do nothing.
Rang De Basanti!
Reservation saga continues
I have been following the reservation debate in India and it is disgusting what self-serving individuals like Arjun Singh will do for a few votes and to get close to the feet of his "Most Favored Master" in Delhi.
All these protests, all this divisive shit so one guy can further his political ambitions?
Truly disgusting! Are one man's political ambitions enough to endanger the fragile cohesion in a billion strong country? Evidently they are...and his political masters do nothing to rein him in or chuck him out.
Rather than increasing total number of seats in central institutions Manmohan Singh and Sonia should show their commitment by throwing out dolts like Arjun Singh flat and square on his ass.
No data is collected or currently available to understand the socio-economic performance of OBCs in Indian society. It is a self defeating assumption that if the title OBC is associated then he/she must be badly off. Most of the OBC seats seem to be taken not by the poor and worthy but by the "creamy layer" of OBC strata. Such individuals might have taken benefit of such lax reservations for generations on end. There is no mechanism to stop such individuals, who have gained from the system once, to stop mooching off the mammaries of the welfare state again and again.
Certainly, you can see the rationale why many of the truly SC/ST/ VJNTs need some reservations...cut the pie by class or caste and they seem to come out the losers in society. They do need a helping hand...but the helping hand needs to be in the shape of empowerment and not in the shape of alms or crutches.
Reservations by themselves are not very wrong...but doling it out on the basis of caste certainly is. And it is obviously the politicians pandering to the whims and fancies of their caste based vote banks. If reservations have to be fair in nature they need to be based on class or socio economic ability. There are many "higher caste" individuals who have as less a say in the system as some of the SC/STs yet there is no effective mechanism to give them a helping hand yet a rich OBC kid, who goes to school in a chauffeur-driven car can take advantage of reservations, albeit with the small irritance of having to produce a "No creamy layer" certificate.
In India's corruption riddled system, such a document is easily procured.
Further, increasing seats to accomodate new reservations so that the total no. of open merit seats are not reduced is not a sustainable activity. Every seat is tied not only to costs but also to resources a student needs to actually learn something- instructor-to- student ratio, hostel facilities, class rooms, laboratory and computing resources, patient beds (for medical education) are all vital factors.
Randomly increasing seats will only serve in diluting the learning potential for all involved.
Also it will bring out more graduates with the strong credentials (IIT, IIM) but not the skill sets. This will further result in the brand name of these institutions being tarnished...brand name not only in the marketing sense but the true underlying competency assumed to be associated with graduates of these institutions.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ahmedabad: The Indian Institute of Management-Ahmedabad “cannot increase the number of seats at this juncture”. Institute director Bakul Dholakia said, “It had its plate full.’’ While the Centre has been talking about an increase in intake of students in elite institutes to ensure that general category remained unaffected while implementing the reservation for OBCs, IIM-A feels it is already brimming. “IIM-A has been on a massive expansion drive. From 180 PGP students in 2002, it has in creased its strength to 280 during its 2006 intake, including 30 students in the agri-business management programme. By 2007, the total intake will be 400, including the oneyear executive MBA programme, PGPX, that will increase its intake from the present 60 to 120,’’ said Dholakia. “In 2007, there will be about 800 students on the IIM-A campus, with 500 students in the first and second year post-graduate programme, 60 students in the ABM programme, 120 in the PGPX programme and about 80 in the doctoral programme. Apart from these, there are participants in the numerous management development programmes for executives that range between one week and a month,’’ said Dholakia. “We require hostel facility to accommodate each students studying in the institute. We have plans to start a management course for bureaucrats with the intake of about 50,’’ he added.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
India has no shortage of political Shylocks who will go out of their way to extract their pound of flesh...but there is only so much flesh that a golden-egg-laying-goose has. After 10 Arjun Singhs have doled out 75-80-85% reservations in Parliament, higher level professional education, private sector and public sector jobs...what next?
What will these vultures gnaw, tear and bite at next?
There will be no more freebie left to give out.
But this would have effectively killed merit in the system. At the end of the day you need merit and knowledge to run an enterprise in a global setting, you need merit to understand a medical condition and treat it, you need merit and knowledge to build a 22.5 km bridge through the sea.
The reservation may get you into the seat that is responsible for all these actions...but do I want someone who got 51% in his final medical test and got admission to a Surgical residency on reservation operating on me?
I don't think so. I don't really care if the person was disadvantaged, my life is at stake and I'm not thinking of social equality and opportunity here. i'd be thinking of finding someone who can save my life..I have a feeling so does Arjun Singh. But Arjun Singh with either his horded or inherited wealth can afford to fly off to the US or UK for medical treatment...most of us can't!
Without being casteist just look at the difference between protests by pro- and anti- reservation groups.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ToI 20 May 2006
In Patna, more than a hundred pro-quota agitators marched towards the Dak Bungalow crossing around noon, accusing the media of being biased against them. Two antiriot vehicles and policemen followed them. The protesters went on the rampage and damaged about a dozen cars, including those parked outside The Times of India building. At the Dak Bungalow crossing, they clashed with mediapersons and TV crew, alleging that the media and police were “hand-in-glove’’.
In Delhi’s Jawaharlal Nehru University, a candlelight march taken out to protest the reservation policy on Friday night turned ugly when a scuffle erupted between students supporting the quota and those opposing it.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
On the other hand protests against reservations have been uniformly civil across the country.
As far as I know there has been no instance of any violent activity by anti-reservations protestors.
More on this later...
All these protests, all this divisive shit so one guy can further his political ambitions?
Truly disgusting! Are one man's political ambitions enough to endanger the fragile cohesion in a billion strong country? Evidently they are...and his political masters do nothing to rein him in or chuck him out.
Rather than increasing total number of seats in central institutions Manmohan Singh and Sonia should show their commitment by throwing out dolts like Arjun Singh flat and square on his ass.
No data is collected or currently available to understand the socio-economic performance of OBCs in Indian society. It is a self defeating assumption that if the title OBC is associated then he/she must be badly off. Most of the OBC seats seem to be taken not by the poor and worthy but by the "creamy layer" of OBC strata. Such individuals might have taken benefit of such lax reservations for generations on end. There is no mechanism to stop such individuals, who have gained from the system once, to stop mooching off the mammaries of the welfare state again and again.
Certainly, you can see the rationale why many of the truly SC/ST/ VJNTs need some reservations...cut the pie by class or caste and they seem to come out the losers in society. They do need a helping hand...but the helping hand needs to be in the shape of empowerment and not in the shape of alms or crutches.
Reservations by themselves are not very wrong...but doling it out on the basis of caste certainly is. And it is obviously the politicians pandering to the whims and fancies of their caste based vote banks. If reservations have to be fair in nature they need to be based on class or socio economic ability. There are many "higher caste" individuals who have as less a say in the system as some of the SC/STs yet there is no effective mechanism to give them a helping hand yet a rich OBC kid, who goes to school in a chauffeur-driven car can take advantage of reservations, albeit with the small irritance of having to produce a "No creamy layer" certificate.
In India's corruption riddled system, such a document is easily procured.
Further, increasing seats to accomodate new reservations so that the total no. of open merit seats are not reduced is not a sustainable activity. Every seat is tied not only to costs but also to resources a student needs to actually learn something- instructor-to- student ratio, hostel facilities, class rooms, laboratory and computing resources, patient beds (for medical education) are all vital factors.
Randomly increasing seats will only serve in diluting the learning potential for all involved.
Also it will bring out more graduates with the strong credentials (IIT, IIM) but not the skill sets. This will further result in the brand name of these institutions being tarnished...brand name not only in the marketing sense but the true underlying competency assumed to be associated with graduates of these institutions.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ahmedabad: The Indian Institute of Management-Ahmedabad “cannot increase the number of seats at this juncture”. Institute director Bakul Dholakia said, “It had its plate full.’’ While the Centre has been talking about an increase in intake of students in elite institutes to ensure that general category remained unaffected while implementing the reservation for OBCs, IIM-A feels it is already brimming. “IIM-A has been on a massive expansion drive. From 180 PGP students in 2002, it has in creased its strength to 280 during its 2006 intake, including 30 students in the agri-business management programme. By 2007, the total intake will be 400, including the oneyear executive MBA programme, PGPX, that will increase its intake from the present 60 to 120,’’ said Dholakia. “In 2007, there will be about 800 students on the IIM-A campus, with 500 students in the first and second year post-graduate programme, 60 students in the ABM programme, 120 in the PGPX programme and about 80 in the doctoral programme. Apart from these, there are participants in the numerous management development programmes for executives that range between one week and a month,’’ said Dholakia. “We require hostel facility to accommodate each students studying in the institute. We have plans to start a management course for bureaucrats with the intake of about 50,’’ he added.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
India has no shortage of political Shylocks who will go out of their way to extract their pound of flesh...but there is only so much flesh that a golden-egg-laying-goose has. After 10 Arjun Singhs have doled out 75-80-85% reservations in Parliament, higher level professional education, private sector and public sector jobs...what next?
What will these vultures gnaw, tear and bite at next?
There will be no more freebie left to give out.
But this would have effectively killed merit in the system. At the end of the day you need merit and knowledge to run an enterprise in a global setting, you need merit to understand a medical condition and treat it, you need merit and knowledge to build a 22.5 km bridge through the sea.
The reservation may get you into the seat that is responsible for all these actions...but do I want someone who got 51% in his final medical test and got admission to a Surgical residency on reservation operating on me?
I don't think so. I don't really care if the person was disadvantaged, my life is at stake and I'm not thinking of social equality and opportunity here. i'd be thinking of finding someone who can save my life..I have a feeling so does Arjun Singh. But Arjun Singh with either his horded or inherited wealth can afford to fly off to the US or UK for medical treatment...most of us can't!
Without being casteist just look at the difference between protests by pro- and anti- reservation groups.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ToI 20 May 2006
In Patna, more than a hundred pro-quota agitators marched towards the Dak Bungalow crossing around noon, accusing the media of being biased against them. Two antiriot vehicles and policemen followed them. The protesters went on the rampage and damaged about a dozen cars, including those parked outside The Times of India building. At the Dak Bungalow crossing, they clashed with mediapersons and TV crew, alleging that the media and police were “hand-in-glove’’.
In Delhi’s Jawaharlal Nehru University, a candlelight march taken out to protest the reservation policy on Friday night turned ugly when a scuffle erupted between students supporting the quota and those opposing it.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
On the other hand protests against reservations have been uniformly civil across the country.
As far as I know there has been no instance of any violent activity by anti-reservations protestors.
More on this later...
Wednesday, May 17, 2006
Graduation- A few random thoughts
I need to figure out why I write so many "random thoughts" on my blog.
Maybe so I don't need to structure them? Hmmm Plausible enough.
The graduation ceremony was decent fun. No family in sight but not their fault :)
Stan gave a terrific speech...one of the best commencement speakers I have heard. Ginger Graham, CEO of Amylin, was a pretty good speaker- succinct and interesting. Compared to the person last year, well she stood head and shoulders above him.
Overall, the ceremony was short, sweet and painless. Usually I hate long drawn out ceremonies, especially the ending ones.
Lotsa pictures were being snapped...I had mine with a select handful who even wanted a pic with me. Kinda felt lost in the crowd surging with families, friends and what have yous. At the end of the program I felt what I felt at Orientation and through most of the program...a misfit!
I got a bunch of knowledge and experience here...but as far as social life and friends were concerned...it was a bullet in the head, a death kneel.
Maybe so I don't need to structure them? Hmmm Plausible enough.
The graduation ceremony was decent fun. No family in sight but not their fault :)
Stan gave a terrific speech...one of the best commencement speakers I have heard. Ginger Graham, CEO of Amylin, was a pretty good speaker- succinct and interesting. Compared to the person last year, well she stood head and shoulders above him.
Overall, the ceremony was short, sweet and painless. Usually I hate long drawn out ceremonies, especially the ending ones.
Lotsa pictures were being snapped...I had mine with a select handful who even wanted a pic with me. Kinda felt lost in the crowd surging with families, friends and what have yous. At the end of the program I felt what I felt at Orientation and through most of the program...a misfit!
I got a bunch of knowledge and experience here...but as far as social life and friends were concerned...it was a bullet in the head, a death kneel.
Friday, May 12, 2006
Masters No. 2- (Click) DONE
Thought it would never get over.
Funny...it did.
More on what I am thinking ...after all "Cognito ergo sum".
Funny...it did.
More on what I am thinking ...after all "Cognito ergo sum".
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)